Winter Window 2020

Greenmachine

Aulder Than The Internet This Radge
Hibs must have totally expected Dunfermline to accept their offer. It leaves us a bit in the shite to be perfectly honest. I am happy with the other players we have brought in, but I am not going to buy into the spin the club will no doubt attempt to put on this. There is no getting away from the fact that we are substantially weaker in the striker department than we were pre-January.
No way should we have agreed to have let Kamberi's move go through until we had secured another striker. The McNulty deal was always going to eventually happen but I think the huns approach for kamberi came out of the blue (literally). Nisbet will have probably been a target for a long time and as I say they must have been 100% confident that Dunfermline would have accepted one of our offers. Absolute madness to have allowed one of our top strikers to go without getting a replacement secured first.
 

Greenmachine

Aulder Than The Internet This Radge
Catch 22 situation, like would we be happy with a clear second choice signing? Gullan might get his chance now, plenty of us have been saying the youngsters need more opportunities.
Gullan is a good attacking midfielder/winger, not a striker IMO....and is still very raw,
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zab

bigmanandy

Legendary Radge
get tae where though by the end of the season? 6th? 5th at the best efter overhauling the mighty livingston?
Weve caused our own damage with the start of the season, i want better frlm Hibs dude as we all do, we should be challenging top 4 at least but have been a let down, we can only support the team second half of the season and see where we go, im sure come the summer we will reassess and go again.
 

Forzahibs

I'm a Radge Donator
Yeah wanted to come Forza, Dunfermline let him down, we took a punt on a championship player for a pretty decent fee, they could have done with the cash.

Away an don't talk shite , did he tell you this personally or is it something you read from his granny / uncle etc ??
 

Cabbageman

Well-Known Radge
Interesting twitter admin hasn't done the standard "business concluded for the window" tweet? Watch this space, it will as soon as I post this reply
 

bigmanandy

Legendary Radge
Away an don't talk shite , did he tell you this personally or is it something you read from his granny / uncle etc ??
Poor form, would you not be gutted not to come to first class facilitys at a first class club after you'd agreed terms and the been let down by your current club?
 

1875

Admin
Hibs must have totally expected Dunfermline to accept their offer. It leaves us a bit in the shite to be perfectly honest. I am happy with the other players we have brought in, but I am not going to buy into the spin the club will no doubt attempt to put on this. There is no getting away from the fact that we are substantially weaker in the striker department than we were pre-January.
No way should we have agreed to have let Kamberi's move go through until we had secured another striker. The McNulty deal was always going to eventually happen but I think the huns approach for kamberi came out of the blue (literally). Nisbet will have probably been a target for a long time and as I say they must have been 100% confident that Dunfermline would have accepted one of our offers. Absolute madness to have allowed one of our top strikers to go without getting a replacement secured first.

We didnt, when McNulty signed, the Huns signed the Hun *&*^ from Switzerland.
 

Robert Barone

Well-Known Radge
I cannot believe we missed out on Nisbet for a difference in initial fee of around £50k. I'm still being told that it didn't go thru as Pars wanted a higher % sell on than Hibs were prepared to agree...that's from the Fife end. Nisbet was happy to come.



Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
 

Bossie

Well-Known Radge
Hibs must have totally expected Dunfermline to accept their offer. It leaves us a bit in the shite to be perfectly honest. I am happy with the other players we have brought in, but I am not going to buy into the spin the club will no doubt attempt to put on this. There is no getting away from the fact that we are substantially weaker in the striker department than we were pre-January.
No way should we have agreed to have let Kamberi's move go through until we had secured another striker. The McNulty deal was always going to eventually happen but I think the huns approach for kamberi came out of the blue (literally). Nisbet will have probably been a target for a long time and as I say they must have been 100% confident that Dunfermline would have accepted one of our offers. Absolute madness to have allowed one of our top strikers to go without getting a replacement secured first.

I don't see how shedding a three goal striker makes us weaker up top. This has been a very positive window, and results will prove that.
 

Greenmachine

Aulder Than The Internet This Radge
The fact most of our arrivals are loans does not bother me one iota. That's mainly what you get in January. There is very little available in January at our level or above which is going to improve us that we can realistically sign on a permanent deal. A Championship player whom they clearly rated is one such player, and we failed to do the deal....and on top of that we let one of our main strikers leave before we had secured the replacement. I'm sorry, that's what it comes down to. . Doidge and McNulty...that's our two first team strikers until May. They had better not get injured that's all I can say.
 

Desperate Dan

Scottish no british, ya radge
Weve caused our own damage with the start of the season, i want better frlm Hibs dude as we all do, we should be challenging top 4 at least but have been a let down, we can only support the team second half of the season and see where we go, im sure come the summer we will reassess and go again.
Correct and never did enough in this windae tae rectify it. I'm no unhappy with the players we just signed, I'm unhappy with the lack of players we signed, it wisnae enough. They'll be wanting the dosh for season tickets soon nand they'll be trying tae spin this as some sort of success, though whae they think they'll fool is something else. Seasons dropped last year, I believe they will drop again this year (particularly if there's any £££ increase). Time tae get the finger oot.
 
Last edited:
Visit Frutin Travel Visit Robertsons Garage
SUPPORT THE SITE!
March Goal: £70.00
Donations so far: £0.00

Unread Posts

Top