Should Scott Allan Start On Thursday Night?

Should Scott Allan Start On Thursday Night?

  • Yes

    Votes: 71 80.7%
  • No

    Votes: 9 10.2%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 8 9.1%

  • Total voters
    88
SUPPORT THE SITE!
October Goal: £70.00
Donations so far: £35.00

moathibby

Legendary Radge
The stats are there and you can't complain about them but if they are that good and PH is such a good player as they make him out to be then why has nobody tried to sign him ??

As I've said before excellent players do not hang about at Hibs let alone in Scotland for 14 seasons , neither are they constantly over looked at International level by the manager....
How many years was Stanton at Hibs?
 

Robert Barone

Well-Known Radge
Voted yes, we've lacked a bit of creativity last couple of games. Give Allan a more or less free role behind Boyle and Nisbet. Be bold, we're a better team on the front foot imo. Utd have struggled to create and score goals so I think we can afford to be a bit more open than we maybe normally would be away from home.

Tbh I'll be surprised if Jack Ross does start Allan, more difficult to throw caution to the wind when you're the one on the hook for the result if it goes against you I suppose.

If he does start forget giving him any defensive responsibility, he'll try to do it imo but at some stage he'll get caught out. Just tell him to concentrate on winning us the game by creating chances/causing Utd havoc. His appreciation of space and taking up difficult positions to be picked up against St Mirren was impressive after they'd stifled us so well in the first half.

I'd be very selective in the games he does play tho, I dont think most away games from the start would suit him tbh for instance.
 

Smurf

Auld Enuff Tae Know Better This Radge
How does he become match fit if he doesn’t get game time? I’d start him against Dundee United, it would be a good test and indication of where he’s at.
By getting more time. Not 10 mins or unused.
 

AG1337

Well-Known Radge
I voted to start Scott but added I am not sure he will.
Despite the general disappointment with Saturday, we continue to make chances. Our Achilles heel (s) is often failing to defend and not taking chances at the other end.

I would be happy for SA to start, I am equally comfortable if he doesn’t and will keep faith with Jack Ross’s choices.

One thing I am clear about, we are a much better team then DU.
2-0 Hibs
👍🏻
 

whiskas

Just A Radge
I ticked undecided but thinking about it more start him tbh. If he can last 45 he can last an hour. Upping his minutes on the pitch progressively is the only way to manage his illness and his performance on Saturday earns him a start IMO
 

Hibees-Mad

Mad Hibees Radge
Ok then lets go with that. He says that he spoke to a few people on more than one occasion but it wasn't enough to make him leave Hibs//

That then tell me that the clubs he was talking to weren't anything special and it would've been considered a side step more than a step forward.

If a more attractive team with better wages or even playing at a higher level were one of those sides then I am sure it would've been given some serious thought..

You can't make that assumption. Despite being an arse now, Matt Le Tissier was wanted by a lot of clubs at different times, certainly could have gotten more money elsewhere at another side. But he stayed at Southampton, as that's where he wanted to be.

I'm not saying Hanlon is the same as that - but you make assumptions on what he was offered from whom, and his thinking about it.

Can you not just accept that he could have gone somewhere else but maybe wanted to stay at Easter Road?
 

Braehead Cabbage

Baldy radge
Think it all depends on his level of fitness/how long he can play.
If not capable of much more than 45 min then probably better as an impact sub.
 

MSG_07

Well-Known Radge
Thread starter
Scott Allan is a game changer and deserves at least 60 minutes to show if he's up to the task. SA to start for me
 

HenryLB

Donator
You can't make that assumption. Despite being an arse now, Matt Le Tissier was wanted by a lot of clubs at different times, certainly could have gotten more money elsewhere at another side. But he stayed at Southampton, as that's where he wanted to be.

I'm not saying Hanlon is the same as that - but you make assumptions on what he was offered from whom, and his thinking about it.

Can you not just accept that he could have gone somewhere else but maybe wanted to stay at Easter Road?

Does PH have an agent? I know Lewis doesn't and they seem pretty close.
 

Pistol1981....

Just A Radge
You can't make that assumption. Despite being an arse now, Matt Le Tissier was wanted by a lot of clubs at different times, certainly could have gotten more money elsewhere at another side. But he stayed at Southampton, as that's where he wanted to be.

I'm not saying Hanlon is the same as that - but you make assumptions on what he was offered from whom, and his thinking about it.

Can you not just accept that he could have gone somewhere else but maybe wanted to stay at Easter Road?
That's not an assumption , that's common sense. If you are at Hibs and you are speaking to other clubs , you will perhaps speak to clubs out of respect but you surely aren't going to leave for a lesser team or a side that's deemed a side step ??

In any walk of life , you only want to move forward surely ???
 
Want to get rid of the ads?
Sign up For a Private Membership!
Click Here
Top