Part 6 was a very interesting and accurate read though after the first quarter you began to struggle to find that many references to Hibs as its now quite hard to pigeon hole Hibs fans or Hibs as a club into any convenient category.
It's a little unfair on such well researched and excellent analysis but "The Celtc Paranoia" is always bubbling under as I am struggling to remember any concerted booing of the rebel songbook at the 2013 cup final or any other cup final for that matter.
It does happen to both "Celtc" and "Scotland's Shame 2012" at Easter Road though and in equal measure.
It's more complete boredom with their bastardised repoitiore than political as in "Celtc's" case it is quite hard to comprehend that 140 years after mass Irish emigration to Scotland that Scottish people still feel a new to cling on to songs which for the most part are about the Wars of Irish Independence of 1916 - 1923 of 100 years ago.
The "Celtc" author explains the history but doesn't address their relevance to a sporting event in Scotland or the fact that this is now 5th/6th/7th Irish generation who just can't move on.
You actually see this at Scotland v Ireland Internationals where a reasonable number of the Irish away support are indigenous Scots which is in my eyes harmless, but weird as Fk.
Like
@1875 I have no problem with what's being sung but struggle to understand the necessity on a wet Tuesday night at a football match in Dingwall etc.
It's a very enlightening series though but the author seems to be a little reluctant to explain "Celtc's" strong links to British Unionism and the British Establishment calling it instead and fleetingly the 'Labour movement'
It is absolutely everywhere within the clubs history from Sir Robert Kelly to the campaign for a Sir Jock Stein to Brian Wilson club historian and the self styled "Hammer of the Scot's" to Chairman John Reid of Iraq war infamy to Lisbon Lions Billy McNeil and Bobby Lennox strong vocal British Unionists in urging Scots to vote No.
George Galloway is another prominent "Celtic" Unionist who probably sums up many of the supporters who campaign and vote British Unionist but also know the rebel songbook backwards, forwards and inside out yet would still claim vehemently to be Irish Republicans against the hated British state.
I have never yet seen this apparent contradiction addressed by any "Celtic" writer so this would be my suggestion to the author for Part 7 as I did think by Part 5 and 6 he was beginning to struggle to find a Hibs angle.